Avoiding the mistakes of Android in Chrome

I've long been a fan of open-source technology.  I am often deeply frustrated by the proprietary approach taken by some manufacturers and I quickly become annoyed when confronted with situations where my freedom of choice is constrained.

Sure, I'm a Windows user but that doesn't mean that I'm happy about it.

I loathe the digital rights management (DRM) systems that prevent me

G-RRR-RRRR

from playing my music on any device of my choosing.  I detest the region locking that prevents me from playing optical media from other countries.  I avoid music distribution services that require me to install their database for storing digital copies of those tracks.  I simply refuse to patronise services or product ranges that impose these draconian constraints on my right to choose.  

"I am not a number, I am a free man" . . .

Now that I've got that out of the way, let me add that although I celebrate the free spirit of open source, I also appreciate that it is not without its own problems.

Android is bloated and slowing down

Take Android for instance.  Manfacturers, phone service providers can and do customise the hell out of this operating system.  The end result is a complete mess.  New releases of Android from Google are vanilla offerings but because the phone manufacturer or the service provider insists on adding a pile of custom fixes, it can take months before it's rolled out to the customer base.  When it does appear it's weighed down with bloat and in dire need of a diet.  For older devices where the providers are no longer interested in support, that next release may never become available.  

Chromium versus Chrome

Google seems keen to avoid this quagmire with their other faster, slicker, all-round more promising offering, the Chrome operating system.   With Chrome, Google will have control over source code and any changes made to it.  That all sounds rather proprietary, don't you think?  Well, yes it is but here's the difference.  Google will maintain control over the Chrome offering but they will provide an open-source version as Chromium.   Positive changes made by the community to Chromium may well be adopted officially into Chrome but some of the more hare-brained customisations will not be allowed to pollute the pure version.

That to me sounds like a great way to go.   So what will catch on, Chrome or Chromium?  Clearly Google will throw plenty of money at Chrome whereas some equally cash-rich manufacturers and providers may favour the flexibility that the Chromium alternative offers.

It will be very interesting to watch how the two stables co-exist in this fascinating technology space.

Chrome versus Chromium - what's the difference

Google Chrome likely to replace Android

UltraViolet

The Hobbit An Unexpected Journey

It's DRM but not as we know it

When The Hobbit An Unexpected Journey is released in NZ on May 1st (why did we have to wait longer yet again?) it will come with a new service called UltraViolet.  I say new but what I should say is new to New Zealand.  The rest of the world, or at least the parts that big business cares about, has had UltraViolet for quite some time.

So what is it and is it any good?  In short it's digital rights management (DRM) all over again and from what overseas consumers are saying it's about as popular as all other attempts to copy protect audio and video content.

The players

Most of the big studios and media distributors are signed up to UltraViolet through a consortium called the Digital Entertainment Content Ecosystem (DECE).  Sony, NBCUniversal, Fox, Paramount, Warner, Dreamworks and Lionsgate are all in there.

Notable DECE absentees are a couple of companies who really don't play well with anyone else.  Disney spoiled the party by going with their own proprietary system called Keychest and Apple are sticking with their iCloud service.  Oh well, par for the course.

What is it?

UltraViolet is a well funded and industry supported technology that aims to provide consumers with a license to view copyrighted movies on a variety of devices.  It will work on your phone on your computer, your tablet, as long as you download and install all the correct applications and register for all the right accounts.  It should work with desktop TV boxes, DVD and Blu-Ray players, too.  If it doesn't work for you, well clearly you've done something wrong.  I hate it already.

This is not a technology for me - I loathe it just from writing that last paragraph.  Give me a physical disc and I'll be happy.  Why?  Well, the disc is mine (even if the content is not) and unless I lose it or sit on it it should last for as long as I could reasonably expect it to last.   If I want to show it somewhere other than at home I can put it in my bag and take it with me - marvellous, and not very complicated to use.

We've seen it before and we'll see it again

I've had a chuckle looking through some of the reader feedback at Amazon, I've checked out a few forums and I'm pretty certain that I'm not going to investigate this technology any further.  I detest DRM because it doesn't work smoothly, it's much too complicated for the average consumer to comprehend and life is too short to get upset about why a movie won't play, or stream or why it's started jumping and staggering to the point where it's unwatchable.  You can usually rest assured that if the movie industry thinks it's a good idea then the consumer is going to think the opposite.

In a data-capped environment like New Zealand bear in mind that that this technology is another way to rack up some high data traffic if you opt to stream UltraViolet movies from the web.

My choice

I will be buying the Hobbit on Blu-Ray.  Why?  Well it's a great film that will look great in 1080P Full HD, the discs will be packed full of the kind of extras that Peter Jackson is famous for and I've already reserved a space for it on my shelf, alongside the many other great movies that I feel compelled to own.

UltraViolet links

Expanding the Hobbit experience (Stuff)

What you need to know about UltraViolet (TechRadar)

Reviewers hate digital locker (Gigaom)

Why UltraViolet is frustrating (IGN)

UltraViolet can go to hell (Blog comment)

UltraViolet home page

An FAQ about Ultraviolet

Ultraviolet titles at WowHD